Grand jury declines to indict officers who fatally shot man during Dayton mental health call

A car with bullet holes is seen Saturday morning, Oct. 19, 2024, on Rosedale Drive in Dayton following a deadly officer-involved shooting. MARSHALL GORBY/STAFF

Credit: Marshall Gorby

Credit: Marshall Gorby

A car with bullet holes is seen Saturday morning, Oct. 19, 2024, on Rosedale Drive in Dayton following a deadly officer-involved shooting. MARSHALL GORBY/STAFF

A grand jury declined to indict officers who shot and killed a 26-year-old man who reportedly pointed a shotgun at them during a mental health call in Dayton last year.

At 8:36 a.m. on Oct. 19, a woman in the 1700 block of Rosedale Drive reported her son, later identified as Taylor Cotton, was having a mental health crisis and threatening to kill her.

“He needs to go to the hospital,” the woman told dispatchers, according to Montgomery County Regional Dispatch records.

She also claimed he set fire to a neighboring house the previous day.

She called 911 a second time to report he had a gun. In the background of the call a man can be heard threatening to have a shootout.

Multiple Dayton police officers responded and spoke to the woman. Around 8:43 a.m., Cotton returned to the house in a car.

“There was information that he intended to have a shootout with the officers,” Dayton police Maj. Paul Saunders previously said. “He was armed with a long gun, which prompted our officers to immediately call for assistance.”

Law enforcement from multiple agencies, including the Montgomery County Sheriff’s Office and Moraine Police Department, responded.

Crews tried to de-escalate the situation for around 25 minutes. Dayton’s police commander for the hostage negotiation team and a senior crisis negotiator were reportedly at the scene.

Dayton police show a photograph of the weapon the suspect brandish that lead-up to the officer involved shooting. JIM NOELKER/STAFF

Credit: Jim Noelker

icon to expand image

Credit: Jim Noelker

At 9:09 a.m. Cotton got out of the car and reportedly pointed a shotgun at officers.

Six Dayton police officers, one Moraine officer and one Montgomery County sheriff’s deputy fired at Cotton, according to police.

Cotton was reportedly shot multiple times.

Crews began providing medical care until medics could take over. He was transported to Miami Valley Hospital, where he died from injuries.

Investigators later determined the shotgun was unloaded, Saunders said.

On Thursday, the Montgomery County grand jury reviewed the case.

At the request of Montgomery County Prosecutor Mat Heck Jr., two assisting prosecuting attorneys from the Franklin County Prosecutor’s Office were appointed as special prosecutors in the case.

The grand jury did not return an indictment.

About the Author